The change in total funding per pupil is summed up by this graph:
Federal allocation of ARRA funds to education was $97.8B. N.Y. received $4.4 billion more federal funding than N.J.. Some of this difference can be explained by demographics. First, N.Y. was eligible for more aid through the State Fiscal Stabilization Funds ($53.6B) simply because it was a larger state. N.Y. ($3.8B) had 6.2% of the nation's population in age group 5-24, while N.J. ($1.3B) had 2.7%. Second, Title I funding ($10B) was for low-income schools. N.Y. ($0.9B) had a greater proportion of students from low-income families, 46% vs 31% in N.J. ($0.2B). Third, IDEA Grants ($12.2B) were for special education students. The number of special education students in N.Y. ($0.8B) was greater than N.J. ($0.4B). Finally, N.Y. ($0.7B) qualified second in Race to the Top (RTT), a program designed to reward states with high-performing schools and educational improvements. RTT funding was dispersed to the top 10 states, while N.J. placed eleventh.
State funding also showed major differences. The first major difference is N.J.'s state law which requires the state budget to balance every year. A state budget deficit cannot be carried forward to the next fiscal year like it can be in N.Y.. In addition, N.J. state tax revenues declined much more than state tax revenue in N.Y. following the Great Recession.
I find this study interesting for several reasons. First, it quantifies part of the impact of the last federal stimulus package (total ARRA bill was $787B). Today, the federal government is again considering a stimulus program which would look starkly different due to its reliance on tax cuts rather than increased spending. Second, it quantifies the impact the recession had on two state budgets which one might assume at the outset to be quite similarly. Finally, the article shows how school budgets react to severe budgetary change.
A Tale of Two States: The Recession's Impact on N.Y. and N.J. School Finances by New York Federal Reserve Bank